For this week’s match up, special guest Lyndsy joins hosts Ruth and Kristen in the competition between While You Were Sleeping (1995) and You’ve Got Mail (1998). We discuss how sadness integrated into the storylines, if Joe Fox is a redeemable asshole, why "coma guy" was put on a pedestal and how Meg Ryan messed up big time by rejecting Tom Hanks’ declaration of love before meeting ‘NY152.’